有谁知道这篇文章出自哪里?FollowingMartinWedell’spiece“Localteacherornativespeaker?”nowisperhapsagoodtimetoexplorethediscomfortovertheuseof“Nativespeaker”(NS)and“Nonnativespeaker”(NNS).Thediscom

有谁知道这篇文章出自哪里?

FollowingMartinWedell’spiece“Localteacherornativespeaker?”nowisperhapsagoodtimetoexplorethediscomfortovertheuseof“Nativespeaker”(NS)and“Nonnativespeaker”(NNS).Thediscomfortnay,stempartlyfromthefactthattheword“native”issometimesmisguidedlyusedtomeanaprimitivesortofsavage;alsopartlybecausetherewillbeanincreasingnumberofexpertEnglishusersallovertheworldwhodidnotstarttheirlivesspeakingEnglish.Theexpression“mothertongue”maybesufferingthesameguiltcomplex.IsitfairtobrandagirlaNSRSofEnglishbecausehermotherwasaFrenchspeakerwhileherfatherspokeEnglish?“Fathertongue”then?Orshouldithavebeen“motherlandtongue”?Fairerevenmightbe“environmenttongue”forchildrengrowingupinanEnglishspeakingenvironment(eventhoughtheirparentsmightspeakanotherlanguageathome).

StudentsoftentellmethattheycometotheU.K.becausetheywanttolearn“pure”Englishinthe“original”environment.WhileIagreethatlearninginanEnglishenvironmentleadstomoreeffectiveEnglishlearning,this“purity”isadangerousconceptandIbelieveitiscloselylinkedto“mother”valuesandtheterm“nativespeakers”.

“Motherland”and“fatherland”implyapatrioticloveforone’scountry,butlanguagecannoteasilyworkinthisway,particularlywhenitisa“worldlanguage”wearetalkingabout.True,languageiscloselyrelatedto“culture”but,formostmodernusersofEnglishintheworld,languageismoreaboutinternationalcommunicationthannationality.

Termssuchas“monolingual”,“bilingual”and“multilingual”maybemoreappropriateforthefuture.Orperhapsthefairestwayistoeliminatealtogethertheneedfortheseterms.ThereissomeconcreteevidencethatNNSand“mothertongue”arealreadylosingtheirinfluence.

TostudyfortheRSACambridgeCertificateorDiplomainTeachingEnglishasaForeignLanguagetoAdults(CELTAorDELTA),teachertraineesnolongerneedtohaveEnglishastheirfirstlanguageandthereisnomentionofNSorNNS.TheCELTArubric,forexample,statesthatparticipantsmustbe“abletousewrittenandspokenlanguageintheclassroomwhichisclearandcoherentandessentiallyfreeofmistakesinspelling,punctuationandgr